From ‘STOP’ to ‘START’: How to Reduce Opt-Outs by 40% Without Sending Fewer Messages

October 31, 2025 Marketing
reducing-sms-opt-outs

In the dynamic world of SMS marketing, low opt-out rates are not just a nice bonus—they’re a foundational sign of health in your list and channel. To put this into context: industry analyses now place average SMS opt-out/unsubscribe rates at less than ~3% in 2025. More narrowly, one research benchmark sets the “healthy” target at under ~1.5% for many lists. (Adam Connell)

Given this backdrop, reducing opt-outs by as much as 40% is absolutely realistic—if you shift your mindset from “avoiding STOP replies” to “starting meaningful conversations.” Below, we’ll look at why opt-outs happen, what the data reveals about root causes, and how you can systematically reduce opt-outs without reducing your send volume.

Why Opt-Outs Matter (Beyond the Obvious)

• Signal of subscriber dissatisfaction

An opt-out isn’t just a loss of a contact—it’s an alert. Regular or elevated opt-out rates signal one or more of these issues:

  • Message frequency is misaligned with expectations or preferences. (MarketingProfs)
  • Content lacks relevance or perceived value. (Falkon SMS)
  • Timing or context is off (e.g., sending at wrong hours, or to the wrong segment).

• Deliverability & sender-reputation risk

Many platforms tie list health metrics (including opt-outs) to carrier routing or deliverability proxies. High opt-outs may lead to worse inbox placement (or SMS equivalent) over time.

• Growth & ROI lock-in

You can send fewer messages and keep opt-outs low, but then you sacrifice scale. Better is keeping your send volume and improving list longevity. As researcher Adam Connell notes, 0.3%–0.6% opt-out rates for campaigns are common when done right; above ~1.5% signals trouble. (Adam Connell)

What the Data Tells Us About Opt-Out Risk

Here are key findings that help decode where losses happen:

  • One source shows “73% of consumers would unsubscribe from an SMS marketing program due to too many messages”. (Ecommerce Bonsai)
  • Another reports “69% would unsubscribe if they received the same message many times”, and “62% would unsubscribe if messages don’t have a purpose”. (Ecommerce Bonsai)
  • According to survey data: in 2025 roughly 84% of U.S. consumers say they’re opted-in to receive texts from at least one business (up from 62% in 2021). (MarketingProfs)
  • And a broad benchmark: opt-out rates sit consistently below ~3%, with many brands reporting <1.5%.

The takeaway: opt-outs are and will remain rare—which means when they happen, it’s a strong signal. And because each message is a chance to either increase trust or decrease it, the key becomes sending smarter, not necessarily sending less.

Three Levers to Reduce Opt-Outs (and Boost Engagement)

Below are proven levers you can pull—each anchored in industry-backed strategy.

1) Set clear expectations up front

One of the strongest drivers of opt-outs is the mismatch between subscriber expectation and actual message experience.

  • At opt-in time, clearly communicate what kind of messages, how often, and what value the subscriber will receive.
  • Include the unsubscribe (“reply STOP”, etc.) instructions in your welcome message and opt-in flow. Transparent opt-outs build trust. (Omnisend)
  • Use a welcome series (e.g., 1–2 messages) that outline the relationship and build value immediately (e.g., exclusive offer, helpful tip) rather than starting with a generic blast.

2) Segment, personalize, and respect cadence

Mass blasting every subscriber with the same message is a fast track to opt-outs. Instead, focus on relevance and timing.

  • Segment your list by behavior or lifecycle: e.g., new subscribers vs lapsed customers vs VIPs.
  • Personalize content—not just “Hi {first_name}” but content that matches interest or past interaction.
  • Respect cadence: data shows consumers prefer receiving texts every other week (≈49%) and only ~34% are comfortable with weekly messages. (SimpleTexting)
  • Use data-driven send times (consider time-zones and day-parts) to avoid “off-hours” irritations.

3) Focus each message on value and call-to-action

If subscribers feel like every text is purely promotional, they’ll tune out. The mix must deliver value.

  • Ensure each message includes something the subscriber clearly wants (an exclusive offer, useful update, relevant reminder).
  • Limit promotional-only messages; consider adding “info”, “behind-the-scenes”, or “VIP only” type of texts.
  • Monitor opt-out rates per campaign. If a particular message type triggers above-average opt-outs, pause and recalibrate. (Textedly)

Why This Works for 2025 and Beyond

  • With ~84% of U.S. consumers opting in to business texts (2025 data) (SimpleTexting), there’s major upside in engaging rather than shrinking your list.
  • Because SMS open-rates remain extremely high (≈ 98%) (Emarsys), the risk of “message never seen” is low—but the risk of message irritation remains high if context is wrong.
  • Opt-outs being rare (as noted above) means that reducing even a small absolute number becomes meaningful for retention, list health and ROI.

In short: you’re working with a high-attention channel. That makes every message count. If you fine-tune your list so that more messages are welcomed, you don’t have to send fewer—they just need to hit in a more engaged way.

When you reframe opt-outs not as a compliance checkbox but as a conversation failure, you unlock smarter design. Focus on:

  • Getting permissions and expectations right up-front
  • Segmenting and personalizing so messages stay relevant
  • Delivering value (and not just promotions) at a cadence subscribers expect

If you commit to that model, you can absolutely see a 40% (or more) reduction in opt-outs — while continuing to scale your SMS sends and deepen the revenue you derive from this high-impact channel.

Sources